Spaces, Places and Possibilities is a research project that explores ways of integrating urban systems modelling with visualization techniques to better capture and convey potential outcomes of social and physical infrastructure decisions to local government and stakeholders. The research will first involve modelling different community development scenarios in order to examine possible outcomes of taking a particular development direction and implementing certain community policies and programs. The research will then use the output from the modelling work to build interactive, useful and beautiful visualizations, which will be used to gain a more salient understanding of the potential outcomes and impacts associated with the scenarios. The objective of the research is to investigate the challenges and opportunities of using urban systems models as a basis for building visualizations that can effectively engage and clearly communicate to users the benefits and trade-offs of different development paths.
This project is being conducted in the community of Squamish, BC, and it is being done in collaboration with Quest University Canada. We gratefully acknowledge the funding provided through the Banting Postdoctoral Fellowships and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (SSHRC) Partnership Engage Grants program.
About this photo: Image of downtown Squamish at the intersection of Victoria Street and Cleveland Street (photo taken by Robert Newell)
Scenario modelling was done in four stages: (1) designing a systems model and community scenarios (i.e., different community development patterns), (2) modelling the scenarios, (3) evaluating the model through community focus groups, and (4) refining the model and scenario based on the feedback. The first stage involved assembling a local government and community stakeholder focus group to discuss issues and possible futures for Squamish. Analysis of focus group data informed the design of a community systems model and local development scenarios. The second stage applied the systems model to examine potential outcomes of the scenarios. Modelling primarily used ArcGIS and R, and explored a variety of factors including access to amenities and education, walkability, parks/trails, food and farm systems, public transit, housing affordability, threats to critical habitat, etc. The third and fourth stage involved another focus group to solicit feedback on the model and scenarios, and then refinement based on the feedback.
Below is the community systems model that guided the scenario modelling process. Grey polygons represent the drivers (i.e., population growth) and constraints (i.e., land availability) of the model, blue rectangles represent land-use types, brown ovals represent development strategies/approaches, and orange ovals represent community outcomes. Green and red lines respectively represent positive and negative relationships.
Mouse over the different elements to see the systems relationships
The modelling work done in this project builds on previous research, in particular the Places + Spaces and Co-benefits of Climate Action projects.
Places + Spaces, which was a project that developed a tool for Canadian communities to assess alternative development pathways. Pathways are influenced by levers (policy options, investment choices in social and physical infrastructure) and impacts (community wellbeing, resource consumption and financial viability). The 'engine' of this tool — which traces the complex relationships between levers and impacts — was an integrated systems simulation model of the community incorporating community-specific data and reflecting community-specific policies and scenarios.
Co-benefits of Climate Action was a research effort that explored benefits experienced from climate action strategies that are not directly related to mitigation or adaptation, for example, increasing community walkability both decreases greenhouse gas emissions and contributes to health of local residents. 'Mapping' co-benefits can illuminate relationships between climate action and other aspects of community development. These maps can be used to gain holistic impressions of the advantages and disadvantages associated with different plans and strategies, which in turn can inform integrated community planning.
Visualizations were created that depicted the different community scenarios (i.e., ways the community can develop). Methods for building the visualizations involved a combination of mapping technology and video game development software, and they were developed as realistic, immersive virtual environments. Users can navigate the visualizations from the first-person perspective and toggle between (and compare) scenarios using keyboard commands. Below is a demonstration video that shows a user exploring one of the visualizations and different community scenarios.
Participatory approaches to developing planning tools, January 2019
Stakeholder-driven modelling for integrated community planning, September 2018
Rob Newell (Principal Investigator) is a Banting Postdoctoral Fellow in the School of Environment and Sustainability at Royal Roads University. He is leading the Spaces, Places and Possibilities research project, which explores the use of systems modelling and visualization techniques to capture and convey potential outcomes of social and physical infrastructure decisions to local government and stakeholders. Rob is also involved in community climate action research (MC3), leading projects on decomposition analysis and climate action co-benefits. His previous work has involved exploring different ways of engaging diverse groups in sustainability research and ideas, such as through data visualizations, social media, and animations. Rob has a PhD in Geography, and his doctoral research involved using video game development software to build a realistic interactive visualization of Sidney Spit Park (Sidney Island, BC) as a tool for participatory planning.
Ann Dale (Trudeau Fellow Alumna, 2004; Canada Research Chair, 2004-2014; Director, School of the Environment and Sustainability, Royal Roads University) is the head of the Community Research Connections program. Professor Dale, with her extensive background in public policy and government, brings a wealth of practical and theoretical knowledge to the team. Believing that both place-based and virtual communities are essential for solving modern day problems, she is deeply committed to expanding the public space for critical dialogue and asking the ‘right, hard’ questions. She currently leads and collaborates on several research projects.
Ian Picketts is a Professor of Physical Sciences at Quest University Canada. His research includes climate change adaptation in the city of Prince George, where he worked with a variety of partners to develop a climate change adaptation strategy and implement actions in policy and practice. One of his primary interests is exploring how to effectively communicate complex information so it can be applied in real-life. His current research focuses on how the impacts of climate change interrelate with the impacts of resource development in northern watersheds. Prior to Quest, Ian taught at UNBC, including courses in outdoor recreation, natural resources, and environmental planning, and once worked as a park ranger. In his spare time he is involved in cycling advocacy and energy development issues in northern BC.
Jaigris Hodson is a Program Head and Professor with the College of Interdisciplinary Studies, Royal Roads University. Jaigris Hodson’s research specializes in understanding how people interact with digital technologies, such as social media, and the content that is produced and shared using those technologies. She has published research in a wide range of academic publications and non-academic publications. Hodson has written on technology for the Huffington Post Canada and the Conversation Canada and is regularly asked to comment on technology stories for local and national media outlets. She is also a sought-after speaker, discussing technology trends and their impacts on industry with organizations as the Canadian Optometric Leaders Forum, Social Media Camp and the Canadian Country Music Awards. Hodson is currently working on two Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council funded research projects. The first examines the ways we can use digital curation to help Canadians better access the work of researchers and the second looks at the experiences of female scholars who have been subjected to online bullying.
The District of Squamish is located at the northern tip of Howe Sound, mid-way between the City of Vancouver and the Resort Municipality of Whistler. The community is situated within the traditional territory of the Squamish Nation and within the boundaries of Electoral Area D of the Squamish-Lillooet Regional District. Recognized as the Outdoor Recreation Capital of Canada, Squamish offers world class hiking and mountain biking trails, rock climbing, kite boarding, wind surfing, kayaking, ski touring, snowmobiling along with countless other outdoor activities. One of the fastest growing communities in Canada, Squamish offers a breathtaking natural setting, convenient access, vibrant arts and culture scene, range of education opportunities, affordable housing, and an expanding and diverse business community.
Nate McCarthy is an undergraduate student at Quest University Canada studying urban geography and political economics. With strong and expansive experience in community leadership, advocacy, and communication, he is currently serving as the Quest University Students' Association President after spending the past year as an Editor-in-Chief for the university's student news magazine. Nate's academic focus is in the productive role of urban space through corporate finance and cross-sector integration. His undergraduate thesis investigates the influence of Amazon's corporate strategy and headquarter development on the Seattle metropolitan area and political autonomy.
Melon Davis is an undergraduate student at Quest University studying ecology and wildlife biology. He is contributing to the visualization component of the Spaces, Places and Possibilities project in Squamish, working to provide an interactive model for community response to different community development pathways. He has a special interest in ornithology and the philosophy of human/non-human animal relationships. Academically he is still working on his senior thesis (titled a Keystone at Quest) on assessing the potential of thermal infrared cameras in surveying and monitoring wildlife.
Stefan Navarrete joined the Spaces, Places, and Possibilities research project as a student researcher at Quest University Canada. While in university, he studied how the physical design and regulation of the built environment could be used to create healthy and diverse communities. For his undergraduate thesis, he created a conceptual design of a mixed-use affordable housing building as a way to address Squamish’s housing crisis. Having a strong interest in exploring how design can help improve the world around us, Stefan is continuing with this research by contributing to the visualizations of this project.